Atlanta, who won the first match of the best-of-three final on Monday, slipped 3-0 behind after failing to win any of the first 11 holes.
They narrowed that gap to 3-2 after 13 before dropping the hammer, which made the penultimate hole worth two points.
And Horschel glided across the green after holing an 18-foot downhill putt that edged his side ahead.
“I hit the spot, it looked good. Two feet out I knew it was in the hole and I blacked out,” Horschel said.
“I think I said some expletives. I think I said something about this being my house. It was a lot of fun.”
New York dropped the hammer for the final hole to try and snatch the game but after both players missed the green, Cantlay’s delicate pitch landed within a foot of the hole to seal the win.
The innovative technology-led indoor tournament was founded Tiger Woods and Rory McIlroy, who said they wanted to help take golf “into the 21st century”.
“It’s completely exceeded my expectations,” said two-time major winner Thomas. “The competitiveness, once the play-offs got here, it was not chippy, but it was competitive. We wanted to win.”
Read article in full at source
Stay informed about this story by subscribing to our regular Newsletter